FEATURE:
Groovelines
Destiny's Child – Survivor
__________
NOT only am I…
writing about albums celebrating big anniversaries this year. I am also including important singles. One of which is Destiny’s Child’s Survivor. Taken from the album of the same name, the single was released on 6th March, 2001. The album came out on 25th April, 2001 and it is the third studio album from the group. Their final album of completely original material was Destiny Fulfilled of 2004. Of course, the members of the group and the line-up of Destiny’s Child shifted. From a four-piecer to a trio, Survivor is a significant single, as it was the first that featured Beyoncé Knowles, Kelly Rowland, and Michelle Williams. What many fans consider to be the best and classic line-up, you can hear the instant bond, unity and brilliance of the three artists. Also, after Destiny Fulfilled was released in 2004, the three members did have their own solo careers. Whilst Kelly Rowland had a string of solo albumns, the most recent being 2013’s Talk a Good Game – and turns forty-five the day this feature is being shared (11th February) -, maybe her best work was as part of Destiny’s Child. Michelle Williams released her most recent album, Journey to Freedom, in 2014. Of course, Beyoncé is the most consistent. Her most recent was 2024’s COWBOY CARTER. Whilst she is one of the most influential and extraordinary solo artists in the world, there is something about her being part of Destiny’s Child, and those three women coming together, that is extra special. You wonder whether we will get another album. Consider the state of U.S. politics and how women’s rights are pretty much not considered by President Trump, a trio like Destiny’s Child seem to be more important and needed. Also, they could shout out to incredible women in music and society. Collaborate with some of them on an album. The trio have performed together in the years since their final album together.
However, there is something about Destiny’s Child you do not get with any other group. Rather than it being a commercial move or tied to an anniversary, there is this love and friendship. Considering how Williams and Rowland are these philomel artists but have not put out their own albums in over a decade, it would be amazing to hear them on record with Beyoncé. Girl group and legends from the 1990s and 2000s are reuniting and touring again. New girl groups are coming through and, whilst you might think of Destiny’s Child as a band and not a girl group, there is no doubt they have influenced so many women on the scene now. Seeing these original three queens on stage or in the studio would be a dream. A destiny re-fulfilled! It would be too late to mount anything to mark twenty-five years of the Survivor album. However, something in some form this year, I know, would get a lot of excitement from fans around the world. Even though 1999’s The Writing’s on the Wall might be my favourite Destiny’s Child album, I feel Survivor is the most accomplished and confident album from Destiny’s Child. Given the personnel shift (members LaTavia Roberson and LeToya Luckett split from Knowles and Kelly Rowland. They replaced by Michelle Williams and Farrah Franklin. Franklin was also dismissed from the group). Survivor, to me, always felt like this feminist anthem. This call of strength and defiance that was for all women around the world, instead, it has different origins and inspirations. The fact the media were criticising and almost joking that the line-up of Destiny’s Child kept changing and mocking that. Knowles was inspired to turn that negativity into something positive and anthemic. I shall come to that. I know there will celebration around the twenty-fifth anniversary of Survivor in April. However, as its titular single has that anniversary on 6th March, I wanted to look ahead. It is amazing how incredible that Survivor album is. Songs like Emotions and Dangerously in Love. The first four songs are Independent Women Part I, Survivor, Bootylicious and Nasty, the trio meant business!
I want to start with this article that tells the story behind the epic Survivor. How it came to be and what its legacy is. It is not only seen as one of Destiny’s Child’s best songs. It is placed up there with the best singles of that decade. In a really tough and strange year (2001), Destiny’s Child and Survivor did give a lot of people strength:
“You all know Beyoncé-beautiful, with large eyes and a stunning smile. She has previously been described by Vogue as “wholesome and sexy at the same time.”
You also know Kelly Rowland, and if you don’t, ask Silas Nyanchwani.
Beyoncé’s mother Tina was not impressed with the name “Girl’s Tyme” and like any mom would do, she sought God’s guidance on a suitable name for the girl band. It wasn’t strange when Tina pulled the word “destiny” out of the bible for her daughter’s girl group. Her husband Mathew-Beyoncé ‘s father, added the word “child.”
And that is how Girl’s Tyme became Destiny’s Child, comprising members Beyoncé Knowles, Kelly Rowland, LaTavia Roberson, and LeToya Luckett.
In the years that followed, Destiny’s Child became known for line-up change more than for hit songs. In 1997, their lead single “No No No” from their self-titled debut album in 1997 became a success, but the group was still struggling…
In 2000, a popular reality TV show called “Survivor" was born in America. The show is a competition reality series in which a group of contestants are stranded on a deserted island and compete in challenges to win a grand prize. The contestants must work together and strategize to outwit and outlast each other, all while surviving the elements and living on limited resources.
Pundits and skeptics started comparing Destiny's Child to the show “Survivor” because of the group’s internal competition and struggles. It was a question of “who will be the last to survive.”
After 3 members left the group, according to the LA Times, some people even joked that Luckett, Roberson, and Franklin had been “voted off the island,” just like an episode of Survivor.
Beyoncé and Kelly Rowland were not happy with the comparisons and negative chatter. Michelle Williams had then joined the group.
Who was going to survive?
Instead of feeding the sceptics, Destiny’s Child wrote the song "Survivor" in response to rumors of the group's break-up and industry pressure to produce a hit single. The lyrics of the song highlight the group's strength and determination in the face of adversity. The song's message of resilience and perseverance resonated with audiences, just as the TV show "Survivor" did.
Nelson Mandela said that criticism prevents a person from becoming a demi-god; for Destiny’s Child, criticism fueled their songwriting; they also drew inspiration from the hit competition series to create the group’s most popular track to date.
The song Survivor went on to win the Best R&B Performance by a Duo or Group with Vocals at the 2002 Grammy Awards.
Today, Survivor is still Destiny’s Child’s second highest-debuting single and currently holds a spot on Billboard’s list of 100 Greatest Girl Group Songs of All Time”.
It’s incredible to think that Survivor got mixed critical reaction when it was released as a single. Such an emphatic and instantly memorable song, luckily critical opinion shas shifted. Maybe criticism around Destiny’s Child and line-up changes. However, take the song solely on its merits as a piece of music and it is one of the strongest songs of the 2000s. In 2016, fifteen years after the release of the Survivor album, some keys places in its creation reflected on its making and success. Near the start of the feature from Entertainment Weekly, we learn a little about the title song:
“DAN WORKMAN (Engineer): When they started Survivor, they were really in a different point in their careers. At the end of every session, I’d get a call from [Beyoncé’s father and the group’s manager] Mathew [Knowles] or someone at the label who wanted to know how it went. The expectations were very high. It wasn’t nearly as relaxed as it was before. There was a sense that the stakes were raised. When we were doing The Writing’s on the Wall it became really obvious to me that the heavy lifting was going to be done by Beyoncé and that Kelly Rowland was the closer. The other girls [who left the group] were not as talented and were not as involved in the creative process. When Michelle came, it was never directly spoken about other than like Destiny’s Child is a trio. No in-depth discussion.
MICHELLE WILLIAMS: Beyoncé was tired of people talking about the Destiny’s Child members changing asking, who was going to be the last one to survive? As the new member, I was being protective over the girls because I was just starting to know them. There are member changes in groups all the time. Things happen. I believe in the journey Destiny’s Child had to take to fulfill the group’s mission: to continue to empower everybody.
TONY MASERATI (Mixer): This was the beginning of pushing the limits of how hard a pop song could get. Their instructions were to make sure it would be at the forefront of the sonic footprint of what R&B and hip-hop should be. For somebody at 19 or 20 years old to hear [such] subtleties is not typical. Generally most young artists are like, “Can I be louder or can I be softer?”
J.R. ROTEM (Co-writer, “Fancy”): Beyoncé knows a lot of soul. Their sensibilities were inspired by tastes that are more sophisticated and by jazz”.
I love the singles from Destiny’s Child. Everyone has their own top five and favourites. When it comes to the best of the best, Survivor comes near the top in a lot of critical lists. In 2024, As The Writing’s on the Wall turns twenty-five, The Guardian ranked the singles. They placed Survivor ninth: “Survivor threw so much shade the way of two former Destiny’s Child members that it occasioned a lawsuit. Beyoncé, Rowland and – in an awesome middle eight – Williams sing up a ferocious storm, but its greatness isn’t really in its lyrics, rather the melody and backing to which it harnesses them: forceful and epic enough that their vitriol sounds like empowerment”. In 2014, Huffpost ranked Survivor in eighth: “Beyonce reportedly concocted the "Survivor" theme after hearing a DJ compare the band's controversy to the incipient reality series. The result is a song (and album) that drills home the perseverance motif with fist-pounding severity. It's a karaoke jam best experienced while belting the lyrics in someone's face, but is "Survivor" truly a great song? A catchy one, a canonical one -- but one without the sleekness of "Independent Women" or the restraint of "Say My Name." It's also kind of long. Still, "Survivor" is obviously a classic, and I'll join anyone who dares holler the lyrics at me in a disco-stained karaoke bar”. There are few reviews of the iconic Survivor. However, Drowned in Sound provided their take on Survivor when it arrived in 2001:
“Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm…..What? I said mmmmmmmmmmmm…that is the only word which sums this track up. What? Well, urm, I’m 19 years old, same age as Beyoncé and co, and I have a fetish for sexy female vocals. I’ll admit it. What? It’s not a criminal offence y’know! I’m only mmm-ing about this ickle ditty. Cus you know my mummy taught me better than that!
I really thought I’d had enough of strings in pop songs, until this one, ‘Survivor’. The evil lil’ violins perfectly set the background for this choon, fighting against post-drum’n’bass (I’m making up genre’s again, sorry!) machine blippity bloppity tsh tsh plopping. Then there are the vocals…mmmmm! The centre of what everything else spins around. These are harmonies to tell the world about. So I am. Three layers of gospel vocals jump up’n’down and shake themselves all around, just as adoringly sweet as a freshly iced chocolate cake, still warm from the oven. Or the video, if you will...mmmmm...
Hang on! There’s some words amongst this prize winning perfect picture style. Oh baby. Putting themselves into the head of the genderless working man (and I use that term looser than an American pollution manifesto), re-interpreting the feeling of finishing another day, ready to carry on to fight another. However, this song does challenge the notion of the chauvinist values that still remain in the world around us(like many other DC songs). And what better way to get the message to those that are wrong, than through one of the sexiest video’s ever! What? What do I mean “wrong”? Think how equal the world is. How men treat women in comparison to how women treat men. Just think about it. The new women’s liberation movement will be televised. You will be watching and maybe listening too-ooh….mmmmm…I’m a survivor!”.
On 6th March, Survivor’s title song turns twenty-five. It’s brilliant lead single is played a lot today. It is one of those songs that will continue to have meaning and this potency that will go through the generations. And I do feel the world wants Destiny’s Child to get together. I know there have been discussions and plans before. However, given the state of the world, tied to the way female artists are dominating and so many are fans of Destiny’s Child, it would be great to have them here again. As Kelly Rowland is forty-five today, I wanted to publish the feature now, rather than wait until close to Survivor’s anniversary. It is a song that I really love. So do millions of others. One I think will be played and talked about…
DEACDES from now.
